Plastic-Free Bar Soap: Is It Better for the Planet?

Edited and reviewed by Brett Stadelmann.

A bathroom shelf can fill up surprisingly quickly: hand wash, body wash and face wash, each with its own bottle or pump. Replacing one of those products with a bar of soap seems like an easy way to cut packaging waste. But is bar soap actually better for the environment once ingredients, manufacturing, water use and transport are considered?

For many everyday handwashing routines, the evidence favours bar soap. The answer is not universal, however. How a product is made, how it is packaged and how we use it all matter.

Why the packaging matters

Plastic packaging is a major source of short-lived waste. The OECD’s Global Plastics Outlook reported that, after losses during processing, only 9% of plastic waste generated worldwide was ultimately recycled in 2019. Recycling is important, but preventing unnecessary packaging remains a practical way to reduce demand for new materials.

Liquid cleansers commonly arrive in plastic bottles with pumps or caps. Many soap bars are sold in small cardboard cartons, paper wrappers or without wrapping at all. The difference is visible before the product even reaches the bathroom. Still, a bar individually sealed in plastic will not deliver the same packaging advantage as an unpackaged or paper-wrapped alternative.

For more ideas beyond soap, see our guides to building an almost plastic-free beauty routine and sustainable skincare packaging.

Crate61 Organics bar soaps in colourful paper packaging displayed among green plants.
Crate61 Organics bar soaps in colourful packaging. Image courtesy of Crate61 Organics.

Bar soap vs liquid soap: what does the research say?

A frequently cited 2009 life-cycle assessment by Annette Koehler and Caroline Wildbolz at ETH Zurich compared everyday hygiene products, including handwashing with bar and liquid soap. The researchers considered more than packaging: they examined production, distribution and the way people washed their hands.

As Scientific American’s explanation of the study notes, producing bar soap required about one-fifth as much energy as producing liquid soap in the comparison studied. Liquid soap could also use up to 20 times more packaging. Since liquid soap contains more water, transporting it can require moving considerably more weight for each use.

Those figures describe particular products and assumptions from a study published in 2009, not a guarantee that every soap bar outperforms every liquid cleanser on sale today. Refillable liquid products, concentrated formulas, recycled packaging and different manufacturing methods can change the result.

The water-use trade-off

The same research identified a less obvious disadvantage: people in the underlying handwashing studies used more warm water when washing with bar soap. Heating that additional water creates an environmental impact of its own. The study also found greater agricultural land-use impacts associated with some of the vegetable oils used in bars.

Even with those trade-offs, bar soap came out ahead for the environmental indicators examined in the researchers’ handwashing comparison. The useful lesson is not that bars are impact-free. It is that choosing a lightly packaged bar and using water efficiently can be a sensible combination.

Simple habits, such as turning off the tap while lathering, also complement wider efforts to reduce household water consumption.

How to choose a lower-waste, responsibly made soap

Not all soap bars have the same ingredients, packaging or supply chains. Look beyond words such as “natural” and “eco-friendly” and ask more specific questions.

  • Packaging: Is the bar unpackaged, in recyclable paperboard or wrapped in unnecessary plastic? Check local recycling rules rather than assuming every coated wrapper is recyclable or compostable.
  • Ingredients: Does the manufacturer clearly list the oils, fragrances and other ingredients? A shorter list is not automatically safer or more sustainable, but transparency helps shoppers make informed decisions.
  • Oil sourcing: Are key ingredients such as palm oil, shea butter and olive oil traceable, with meaningful sourcing information or relevant certification?
  • Skin suitability: Fragrance and essential oils can irritate some people, and an appealing sustainability claim does not guarantee that a formulation will suit sensitive skin.
  • Usefulness: Choose a bar that you like enough to finish. An unused product, even one in lovely cardboard, is still wasted material.

Traditional soap is made through saponification, a reaction involving fats or oils and an alkali such as sodium hydroxide. Some cleansing bars instead use synthetic detergent ingredients, often called syndets. That distinction describes formulation, not whether a product is intrinsically safe, ethical or environmentally preferable. Neither “chemical-free” nor “natural” is a meaningful substitute for ingredient and sourcing evidence.

Our broader guide to ethical and sustainable skincare explores how to evaluate marketing claims across personal care products.

Why shea butter and olive oil deserve a closer look

Soap formulas often use a mixture of oils and butters to achieve a particular balance of cleansing, firmness and lather. Shea butter and olive oil are two familiar examples, but their environmental and social footprints depend heavily on how they are sourced.

Shea is associated with West African supply chains in which women have long played an important role in processing. That makes fair compensation and meaningful supply-chain transparency particularly relevant questions for brands using the ingredient. A claim that shea is “ethically sourced” should ideally be backed by evidence about producers, purchasing arrangements or independently assessed standards.

Olive oil comes with questions of agricultural water use, soil management, cultivation practices and transport. Farming without certain synthetic inputs may have benefits, but such claims should be specific and verifiable rather than assumed from a product’s appearance or price.

A Canadian example: Crate61 Organics

Crate61 Organics offers an example of how a bar soap brand can communicate several of these choices. The Canadian company sells cold-processed, plant-based bars in a range of scents, with published ingredient lists. Its product descriptions also identify FSC-certified paperboard packaging and, for relevant formulations, RSPO-certified sustainably sourced palm oil.

For instance, the brand’s Eucamint bar soap ingredient information lists olive, coconut and palm oils alongside shea butter, while explaining the certification claim attached to its palm oil. These are checkable details, although they do not, by themselves, establish the total environmental footprint of the finished product.

Crate61 says its ingredients include shea butter from Ghana and olive oil from Crete. The precise community-level sourcing and farming claims supplied for this article have not yet been independently substantiated, so they should not be treated as verified facts without further documentation.

Whether considering Crate61 or another maker, the most useful approach is to compare the packaging, ingredient disclosure, sourcing evidence and suitability of the bar for your needs.

How to make a bar of soap last longer

Getting the full use out of a bar helps reduce waste and means fewer replacement purchases. These small habits make a difference:

  • Let it drain: Use a dish with drainage holes or a soap saver so the bar does not sit in water and soften.
  • Keep it out of the shower stream: Constant splashing wears a bar down even when nobody is using it.
  • Lather, then set it aside: Wet your hands or a reusable washcloth, create a lather, and put the bar back on its dish.
  • Store spare bars somewhere dry: Avoid damp cupboards and unnecessary bulk buying if you are unlikely to use them.
  • Use the last sliver: Press it onto a new bar or place small pieces in a reusable soap pouch.

Frequently asked questions

Is bar soap always more environmentally friendly than liquid soap?

No. Research on typical handwashing products has found advantages for bar soap, especially in production and packaging, but the result depends on the formula, packaging, sourcing, water use and other circumstances.

Does natural soap mean it is better for sensitive skin?

Not necessarily. Fragrance, essential oils and other ingredients can cause irritation regardless of whether they come from plants. Consider a fragrance-free product if your skin is reactive, and seek professional advice for persistent skin concerns.

Can a soap wrapper go in the recycling?

Plain paperboard may be accepted by local recycling services, but plastic-coated, laminated or heavily contaminated wrappers might not be. Follow the packaging instructions and your council’s rules.

A small swap, not a miracle solution

Replacing disposable bottles with a well-chosen bar soap is a manageable way to reduce bathroom packaging. Its real value comes from choosing a product with credible sourcing information, using it completely and avoiding unnecessary water waste. No single bathroom purchase solves plastic pollution, but consistent, informed choices are more useful than unexamined green claims.